Anthropic must face claims it misled Claude Max buyers about usage, report says
A US magistrate judge let misrepresentation and contract claims proceed but dismissed several others, The Next Web reported, citing Courthouse News.
A US judge has ruled that Anthropic must face key claims that it misled customers about how much use they get from its Claude Max plans, according to The Next Web, citing Courthouse News.
Magistrate Judge Alex Tse allowed claims of negligent misrepresentation and breach of contract to go ahead and dismissed several others on Friday, the outlet reported. The proposed class action, Kahn v. Anthropic, is in the federal court for northern California. The Next Web said it had not read the ruling itself.
The case is about how Anthropic described its paid plans. According to The Next Web, the company told buyers that its $100 and $200 Max plans give five or 20 times more usage than its Pro plan. The lawsuit, filed in June, says the plans give far less over a full week.
The plaintiffs, Karl Kahn and Solomon Smith, calculated that for one Claude model, the $200 plan gives six times Pro's weekly usage and the $100 plan gives 3.5 times, The Next Web reported. The gap comes from how limits work. Max users get five or 20 times more use in each five-hour session, but their weekly limits are not five or 20 times higher.
Anthropic argued that customers should understand the extra usage as applying per session, and pointed to a help page. Tse was not persuaded, according to Courthouse News as cited by The Next Web. The judge wrote:
“Anthropic's per session disclosure is located two hyperlinks away from the primary sales pages on claude.com”Alex Tse, US magistrate judge
Because customers pay monthly, the judge found, they could reasonably read the promise as applying each month.
The ruling means the central complaint, that the advertised usage multiples did not match what buyers got over a week, remains in the case. Other parts of the suit were cut back. Tse dismissed claims under two California laws on unfair business practices and false advertising, The Next Web reported. He also dismissed Kahn's claim under a state consumer law but gave him the chance to add detail, while Smith's claim under that law survived. The judge also rejected a claim that Anthropic acted unfairly by tightening usage limits during billing periods.
Much is still unclear. Anthropic and the plaintiffs did not immediately respond to Courthouse News, so neither side's view of the ruling has been reported. Because The Next Web had not read the ruling, its account depends on Courthouse News. The report does not say what the next steps in the case are or when they will happen.
Separately, Anthropic renamed the Max plans last week, The Next Web reported. The outlet did not give the new names or say whether the change is connected to the lawsuit.